Mutton was a prolific marksman who had three separate spells with The Nomads. He first joined The Nomads in 2002 from Caernarfon Town. In his first season at Deeside, Mutton scored 23 goals from 31 starts. The following two seasons saw Mutton continue his fine form with 31 goals from 63 appearances for The Nomads before joining Rhyl briefly in 2005.

Mutton quickly returned however, only making five starts during his time at Rhyl, and he returned to notch another three goals in 13 starts in the 200-06 campaign. He once again improved his impressive scoring tally on Deeside in the 2006-07 season netting on 12 ocassions from 28 starts before departing in the summer to join Newtown.

Mutton returned to Deeside in the 2008-09 season where he scored two goals from seven starts, leaving his Nomads totals at 71 goals from 142 (+11) appearances.